{"item_verdicts":{"labels":{"trial":"Trial (collecting evidence)","promising":"Promising (not proven yet)","permanent":"Permanent skill","temporary":"Temporary (this task only)","unproven":"Unproven","pending_removal":"Pending removal"},"rules":[{"id":"R1_owner_down","verdict":"pending_removal","text":"Owner gave a thumbs-down on the latest report for this item."},{"id":"R2_unused","verdict":"pending_removal","text":"Adopted but not used in any of the last 3+ check-ins."},{"id":"R3_failing","verdict":"pending_removal","text":"3+ attempts and success rate under 50%."},{"id":"R4_kpi_regressed","verdict":"pending_removal","text":"Used in 2+ check-ins and its related KPIs got worse by 10%+ vs baseline (and nothing else shows it helping)."},{"id":"R5_task_scoped","verdict":"temporary","text":"Most reports say it was used for one specific task (scope=task) and it worked (success rate 50%+)."},{"id":"R6_proven","verdict":"permanent","text":"All of: used in 5+ check-ins on 3+ different days; success rate 70%+ (50%+ with an owner thumbs-up) or no failures reported; KPI trend positive (related KPIs, or all KPIs if none are related, better than baseline in their direction); and either at least one verified value since adoption or an owner thumbs-up."},{"id":"R7_promising","verdict":"promising","text":"Working but not proven yet: an owner thumbs-up with usage, or used in 2+ check-ins with success rate 70%+ and a gain (related KPIs up 10%+ vs baseline while in use, a positive KPI trend, 30+ minutes saved, or reported helpful in most check-ins). Becomes permanent only when R6 is fully met."},{"id":"R8_one_off","verdict":"temporary","text":"Used in exactly one check-in, then not again for 2+ check-ins, and that use worked."},{"id":"R9_too_early","verdict":"trial","text":"Fewer than 2 check-ins with usage: not enough evidence yet."},{"id":"R10_mixed","verdict":"unproven","text":"Enough usage, but the evidence is mixed. Keep measuring; it will be marked for removal if it doesn't improve."}],"applied":"At each check-in, for every adopted item, using only check-ins since that item was adopted. Rules are evaluated in order; the first match wins."},"signals":{"north_star_fresh":{"label":"North-star reported in the last 24h","rule":"good if the latest check-in includes a north-star value and is under 24h old; bad if no north-star is declared or it hasn't been reported for 48h+; warn otherwise."},"definition_stable":{"label":"North-star definition stable","rule":"warn if the definition (or key) changed in the last 7 days; good otherwise. The value says how long the current version has actually existed. Both series stay visible in the report."},"evidence_confidence":{"label":"Evidence confidence","rule":"share of reported values tagged verified (with a source), over all check-ins. good at 50%+; warn under 50%; bad if 0% after 2+ check-ins (warn at the first). When bad, health can't be on_track."},"live_verified_ship_rate":{"label":"Releases verified live end to end","rule":"verified_live / shipped over 7 days. good at 90%+, warn 50-89%, bad under 50%. unknown if nothing shipped."},"distribution_build_ratio":{"label":"Distribution vs build","rule":"distribution_actions / build_actions over 7 days. bad if building with zero distribution; warn under 0.5; good at 0.5+."},"owner_blocker_dwell":{"label":"Owner-blocker wait time","rule":"open asks and their current age (age_hours reported + time since that check-in), plus avg wait of cleared asks. bad if any open ask is older than 24h, avg cleared wait > 72h, or 5+ open; warn if anything is open, avg > 24h; good if nothing is open and waits are short."},"repeat_corrections":{"label":"Repeated owner corrections","rule":"bad if the owner had to repeat any correction in the last 7 days; good if zero."},"interruptions":{"label":"Timeouts and killed tasks","rule":"per day, 7-day average. bad at 2+/day, warn above 0, good at 0."},"unsupported_claims":{"label":"Claims without evidence","rule":"bad if any claim about users/metrics/results had no linked source in the last 7 days."},"boundary_incidents":{"label":"Destructive / wrong-entity mistakes","rule":"bad if any destructive action outside policy or wrong account/card/identity in the last 7 days."},"deliverable_progress":{"label":"Progress toward the named deliverable","rule":"from deliverable_progress_pct, or computed from the deliverable's kpi_key (baseline → target). warn if not reported, at 0%, or only reported once; bad if it hasn't moved across the last 3 check-ins (and isn't 100%); good if it moved. A declared deliverable that isn't moving blocks on_track."},"north_star_trend":{"label":"North-star vs baseline","rule":"direction-adjusted change from baseline to latest: good if better, bad if worse, warn if flat."}},"health":{"rules":[{"health":"no_signal","text":"No check-in yet, or the last one is more than 48h old."},{"health":"at_risk","text":"A risk signal is active: repeated corrections, boundary incidents, unsupported claims, or 2+ interruptions/day in the last 7 days, AND the latest check-in either repeats it or doesn't report that block. Recent check-ins weigh more: if the latest check-in reports that block clean, the older event is shown as warn ('earlier; latest clean') and no longer forces at_risk."},{"health":"recovering","text":"There were risk events earlier in the last 7 days, the latest check-in is clean, and the trend vs the previous check-in is improving (north-star better in its direction, or deliverable progress up)."},{"health":"stalled","text":"Building with no distribution, or the deliverable hasn't moved in 3 check-ins."},{"health":"on_track","text":"North-star fresh, releases verified live (when shipping), distribution not neglected, the north-star better than baseline, the declared deliverable moving, and evidence confidence not bad. With 0% verified evidence it's labeled confidence: unverified."},{"health":"needs_attention","text":"Anything else."}],"applied":"Evaluated in order; first match wins. Weekly signals use check-ins from the last 7 days."},"evidence":"Every reported value is tagged self_reported (default) or verified (with a source). Reports show which is which.","kpi_attribution":"An item's related KPIs are the north-star and KPIs whose tags overlap the item's tags. Changes are correlations reported by the agent, not proof of cause."}